Quote from Foxes On Idol

http://www.foxesonidol.com/cgi-bin/ae.pl?mode=1&article=article1115327.art&page=1

Erica:
"The James who was on stage for his second song, the soft singer, is the James that I really like so much. I like him much more than the crazy rocker James even if he is having more fun as the rocker. He sang the song without the theatrics and it was perfect. It was quiet and stunningly powerful. The arrangement highlighted his voice and it was so very lovely and heartfelt. When he reached the belting part towards the end and we saw his tears, it became exactly what I love about music. I mark the moments of my life by the songs the touch me at that time and it was powerful to be a part of such a moment with James. It was intimate and personal and yet it didn’t feel as if we were intruding; we were sharing his moment. For once Randy was right, this may well be his season to lose."

end of quote

Every week the website has two people judge the singers and rate their songs. I haven't read all of Erica's comments, but I get the impression that she has not been the biggest James fan, at least until "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow." So I thought it was important that she liked "Without You" so much.

A Fan